Judge blocks new Indiana panhandling law
July 1, 2020By The Associated Press
INDIANAPOLIS — A federal judge has blocked Indiana’s new tougher anti-panhandling law the day before it was to take effect.
The preliminary injunction issued Tuesday called the Republican-backed law “an unconstitutional prohibition on the freedom of speech.” U.S. District Judge Jane Magnus-Stinson ordered it could not be enforced while the lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union of Indiana proceeds.
The new law aimed to prohibit people from requesting money within 50 feet (15 meters) of sites such as ATMs, business and restaurant entrances, public monuments or the location of a financial transaction, which includes parking meters.
The ACLU argued that would essentially make it a crime to panhandle anywhere in the downtown areas of Indianapolis or other Indiana cities. The group maintained the new law was so restrictive that its staff could not solicit contributions for memberships on Monument Circle in Indianapolis each Sept. 17 on Constitution Day.
Magnus-Stinson wrote that the state attorney general’s office failed to provide evidence linking panhandling to business disruptions or escalations to criminal behavior.
“This case is not a close call, because Defendants submit no evidence whatsoever to support the notion that the statute furthers a compelling governmental interest,” Magnus-Stinson said.
More on DuboisCountyHerald.com
-
Strassenfest theme, Hofmarschalls announced
The Jasper Strassenfest Committee has selected a theme and Hofmarschall for the 2021... -
County sees another COVID-19 death, 46 cases
The Indiana State Department of Health has reported since Friday another COVID-19-related death... -
SW Dubois renovations to include new gym, more
The Southwest Dubois County School Board approved spending up to $5.5 million on renovations in... -
County sees another COVID-19 death, 16 cases
The Indiana State Department of Health reported Friday another COVID-19-related death in Dubois... -
Jasper mayor provides COVID-19 update
The Dubois County Health Department is working diligently to prevent further spread of COVID-19... -
County records 1 COVID-19 death, 31 cases
The Indiana State Department of Health reported Thursday one more COVID-19-related death in... -
Ferdinand looks back on productive year
Despite the pandemic, the town of Ferdinand had a pretty good year in 2020, Town Council... -
County sees 2 COVID-19 deaths, 24 cases
The Indiana State Department of Health reported Wednesday two more COVID-19-related deaths in...