Auction-Packed Place

David Cox of English looked through the stacks of antiques and collectibles yet to be auctioned off at the annual fall machinery, antique, carriage and horse auction at Dinky’s Auction House in Daviess County on Tuesday. The auction draws thousands of antique dealers, horse breeders and curious people from across the United States over three days. Cox owns Midwest Antiques and Collectibles in English and was looking for items for his store.

Story by Tony Raap
Photos by Ariana van den Akker

Rows of antiques — stacked several feet high, in no particular order — lined the entryway.

Workers piled barber chairs across from long, slender columns of wooden chests and heaped musty magazines dating to the 1950s near an old Schubert piano. A pair of ice skates dangled next to a set of shaving mirrors. Sewing machines were crowded in one corner, an assortment of dresser drawers in another.

Metal sculptures awaited buyers outside before the auction. People from all over brought items to sell.

The antiques, numbering in the tens of thousands, spilled into a large open area inside Dinky’s Auction Center near Montgomery, nestled in the heart of Amish country. In the middle of the concourse were two rectangular auction pits, where wooden tables were filled with sleds, frying pans and other items. Auctioneers chanted into a microphone as ringmen scanned the crowd for bids, yelling “Yep!” when a hand shot up.

Earlier this week, thousands crowded into Dinky’s wooden bleachers for the annual fall auction, one of the largest consignment shows in the U.S., where items as diverse as wagons, quilts and Crock-Pots went up for bid. The three-day auction, which ended Thursday, has become more than just a place for vendors to peddle their wares.

Money from concessions supports the local schools, and for many, the auction house is a place to socialize with friends they might see only a few times a year. It is equal parts fundraiser, shopping mall and community-gathering place. Sotheby’s, eat your heart out.

In the age of eBay, Amazon and Craigslist, Dinky’s has flourished in large part because of its location. The 59,000-square-foot auction house is centered in a tiny agricultural community where the nearest Walmart is about 15 minutes away (even longer if traveling by horse and buggy).

Daviess County has more than 1,000 Mennonites and Amish, most of whom live in a world without computers, smartphones or television. If they need something, they go to an auction.

After years of toying with the idea, John Lengacher Jr. bought 40 acres of land near Montgomery and built an auction house in 1996.

“It was started more or less just to provide a place for the local people to go,” said Lengacher, a Mennonite with a neatly trimmed gray beard and piercing blue eyes.

“For the Amish, for recreation, what do you do on Friday night?” he said.

Nostalgia also factored into his decision. As a boy, he would tag along with his father to auctions in nearby Odon.

“I can still remember that auctioneer. He had a cigar in the corner of his mouth, and he’d auctioneer and chew on his cigar at the same time. ... I can still smell that cigar smoke,” said Lengacher, who also owns Daviess County Metal Sales.

Randall Decker of Clarkson, Ky., left, and Trent Dorsey of Big Clifty, Ky., lounged in the wagon that Decker brought to sell at the auction. Decker customized the wagon to have car seats in the front for a more comfortable ride.

The land where the auction house now stands used to belong to Jacob “Dinky” Stoll, a farmer who once lived near Dinkum Creek outside of Washington — hence the nickname. Lengacher thought it was catchy and so the name stuck.

David Sollman of Velpen looked at some of the wagon wheels up for auction. Sollman brought several wheels from old wagons on his property to the auction and wanted to see what they sold for.

“When you name a business, you want it to be short, simple and memorable,” he said. “If you hear ”˜Dinky’s’ once, you’ll never forget it.”

Every Friday night for the last 17 years, items have been put up for bid at the auction house. It isn’t uncommon for these weekly auctions to draw a thousand people.

The fall auction came a few years later. The Amish used to hold horse sales on farms, but eventually the events grew so big that “we just didn’t have enough room,” Lengacher said.

Another large-scale auction is held in the spring, which attracts about the same number of vendors and bidders. Over the years, the consignment sales have become woven into the fabric of the community. Little Amish boys who grew up going to Dinky’s are now auctioneers.  

Levi Raber grew up on a farm about three miles from the auction house. He has been an auctioneer for 12 years, working every Friday night at Dinky’s.

Raber, who also runs a cabinet-making business, said the auctions are a place where the Amish and Mennonites can grab a bite to eat and catch up on the news. Some folks, he said, never place a bid. They come for the social environment.

An Amish family walked toward the horse barn to look at carriages. The carriages weren’t auctioned until the next day, but many people came to look at them Tuesday. By Wednesday afternoon, the barn was filled with horses to be auctioned Wednesday and Thursday.

Others, though, enjoy the thrill of a bidding war. On Tuesday, Mike Traub looked over farm machinery behind Dinky’s horse barn. He and his wife, Theresa, drive from Effingham, Ill., each fall and usually take home a few antiques or a piece of farm equipment.

One ringman pointed to another one who shouted to the auctioneer that there was a bidder. Since Dinky’s is in the heart of Amish country in Daviess County, many of the auctioneers and ringmen are Amish and many Amish come to the auctions to buy and sell goods as well as to socialize.

“I’m pretty loaded up on stuff,” said Traub, a retired farmer. “Unless I find something I just can’t live without.”

But some were looking to sell. Jennifer Tanner and her husband, Lanier, hauled a pair of Belgian horses from their home in Mobile, Ala., hoping to fetch a few thousand dollars at auction.

They have been coming to Dinky’s for years. Over time, they have befriended the Amish.

“Their way of life is so wonderful,” Jennifer Tanner said. “They’re not in a big hurry. ... They just love life.”

She said the auction house, which is ringed by hitching posts for horses and carriages, offers a glimpse of a time gone by.

“I think we’re all looking for something,” she said. “We all live in too much of a hurry.”

On Tuesday afternoon, Eli Knepp, an Amish dairy farmer who lives about a mile from Dinky’s, stood in the shade near the entrance to the auction house. Each year, he meets someone new at the fall consignment show.

The Amish, he said, tend to keep to themselves but also enjoy interacting with “the English,” a term they use for those who live outside their enclave. Earlier that day, he talked to a gentleman who came to Dinky’s for the first time.

He had heard it was a big auction but didn’t realize how big. He told Knepp that next year, he would bring more money and a bigger truck.

A few feet away, the bidding continued. If anything, the crowd had grown since the auction began that morning.

As they moved from one lot to another, the bidders had a gleam in their eye.

The day was still young and full of possibility.

Contact Tony Raap at

More on

  • Rock Solid: Raiders of the Rock Club

    Raiders of the Rock has allowed students to overcome their fears and climb to heights they never...
  • Modern Moms

    From day jobs to side gigs, taking care of the kids, and staying involved in the community,...
  • Tale of the Courthouses

    Since the formation of Dubois County in 1818, the county has had four different courthouses. The...
  • Joy Of The Hunt

    Statistics show that fewer and fewer people hunt; however, one area group hopes to change that,...
  • Prom-ising Costs

    There’s no doubt that costs tied to prom can start to add up. But all the price tags that go...
  • Noted Leader: James Goodhue

    James Goodhue is known for leading the award-winning Jasper band program. However, the...
  • Pottery With A Purpose

    Monte Young has been creating pottery since he was 13. The 57-year-old Jasper man believes in...
  • Frydays In Lent

    Fish fry Fridays in Dubois County are a tradition. Throughout Lent, churches and organizations...