Appeals court throws out man's convictionsFebruary 24, 2020
By The Associated Press
EVANSVILLE — A southwestern Indiana man's convictions on charges of killing his wife and shooting his adult twin daughters have been overturned because the jury forewoman didn't disclose a prior criminal charge and her history as a domestic violence victim.
The Indiana Court of Appeals on Friday ordered a retrial for Clinton Loehrlein of Darmstadt, who was serving a 150-year prison sentence for murder and two counts each of attempted murder and aggravated battery, the Evansville Courier & Press reported. He was convicted last August of fatally shooting and stabbing Sherry Loehrlein, 52, in January 2017 and shooting their two daughters.
The appeals court, in a 2-1 decision, said the juror's “untruthful and misleading responses on the jury questionnaire constituted gross misconduct.” It said the juror's misleading answers deprived Loehrlein of the opportunity remove her from the jury before trial.
The juror later admitted she had faced a domestic battery charge that was later dismissed. She also said she had been the victim of repeated acts of domestic violence by her ex-husband.
Prosecutors had no immediate comment on the ruling.
More on DuboisCountyHerald.com
The Lincoln Amphitheatre is rescheduling its 2020 performance series for 2021.
Farmers markets offer more than just a place for locals to buy and sell fresh produce. They also...
The 2020 Ferdinand Folk Festival has been canceled.
The Dubois County Health Department reported three new COVID-19 cases today, bringing the...
Jasper High School graduated 255 in the Class of 2020 this month when e-learning came to an end...
The wedding of my daughter Delaney and future son-in-law Max has become one of what Knot.com...
The Dubois County Health Department confirms four more positive cases of novel coronavirus,...
The Dubois County Health Department confirms seven more positive cases of novel coronavirus,...