Enduring The Test Of Time

Jon Hurst of Dale used an electric hoist to transport a monument from inside the building at Schum Monuments in Dale to a lot outside Sept. 19. Schum Monuments was founded 125 years ago by Andrew Schum Sr., who later sold the company to his sons Benno and Andrew Jr. Jack Troth married Benno’s daughter Sandy and has been in charge of the company since the late 1970s. Two of Jack and Sandy’s children, Chris and Susan, are a part of the company.

Story by Tony Raap
Photos by Dave Weatherwax

Sandy Troth, the third-generation co-owner of Schum Monuments, slides behind a desk near the front of the shop’s headquarters in Dale.

Family portraits line an office wall, along with newspaper clippings in which the company has been featured. On this morning, Sandy is in the mood to reminisce.

She often wonders how her family’s tombstone business has survived for 125 years.

As with any company, Schum Monuments has been through ups and downs, good years and lean years. Through it all, the business has endured, much like the slabs of granite it sells.

Garrett Southwood of Newburgh, left, and Hurst pushed the large hoist along the track as they worked to fill an empty spot with a new monument stone in the lot outside the business Sept. 19. The company’s original building still stands, but in the 125 years of the business, several additions have been made.

While tracing the branches of her family tree, Sandy’s eyes fill with tears when she talks about her paternal grandfather, Andrew Schum Sr., who founded the company when he was just 17.

“He was such a kind man,” she says.

One day, according to company lore, a family of modest means came to pick out a tombstone. Schum showed them around, pointing out the different monuments on display.

A few minutes later, another customer pulled up in a fancy car. It was obvious that he was a man of considerable wealth.

Several drawers in the workshop at Schum Monuments are filled with thousands of sheets of tracing paper that have artwork on them that is traced on monuments time and again. Some of the drawings are a good 75 years old, Jack Troth said. “If not older.”

As the story goes, he went up to Schum and said: “I’m in hurry and I want to buy a nice stone. Could you help me right now?”

Schum, who was still tending to the less affluent family, stared at him for a second before saying, “Sir, you’re going to have to wait. These people think as much of their dead as you do.”

It’s unclear whether the wealthy gentleman stayed or stormed off. That part of the story has been lost over time. The point is that the family with less money was not shoved aside.

“That’s the kind of guy he was,” Sandy says, her voice choked with emotion. “And that’s exactly why this business is still here — because of the incredible people that have worked here.”

Schum launched the business in 1888 in his father’s barn in Mariah Hill. He learned to carve tombstones by watching a craftsman chisel limestone in Huntingburg.

In 1893, he married Philomena Heilers of Ferdinand. The couple had nine children — five boys and four girls.

Chris Troth, left, and his father, Jack, worked on stencil work for two monuments on Sept. 19 to prepare them to be sandblasted. Before sandblasting was used to create the artwork and lettering on a stone, it had to be done by hand, which often would be the “signature” of the individual who carved it, Jack said.

The business began to take off around the turn of the century, and in 1914, Schum moved his shop to Dale to be

closer to the railroad tracks. Back then, heavy stones were shipped by rail.

At one time, all of his sons worked in the shop. But when he retired in the early 1940s, only two — Andrew Jr. and Benno, Sandy’s father — were interested in taking over the business.

Sandy speaks adoringly of her grandfather, who had white hair and wore black-rimmed spectacles. She remembers combing his long, jutting beard while sitting in his lap.

In 1950, at age 77, Schum died of a heart attack while helping build St. Joseph Catholic School in Dale.

Sandy’s father was at work when he heard the news. He trudged home and knelt on the floor in front of his wife, Sally.

“Dad’s dead,” he told her.

“And he cried like a baby,” Sandy says.

“That was the only time I saw my dad cry,” she adds. “I’ll never forget it as long as I live.”  

Chris Troth slipped on a protective glove as he suited up to sandblast a monument Sept. 19.

Benno later became the sole owner, and in 1978, he sold the company to Sandy and her husband, Jack Troth.

The couple have three children, all of whom have spent time on the shop floor, learning the nuances of the family business.

Their daughter, Susan Teaford, is the office manager, and their younger son, Chris Troth, oversees the work area behind the showroom.

Jack and Sandy’s other son, Mike Troth, is not involved in the business. He works as a computer programmer for Ashland Oil in Lexington, Ky.

“Just wasn’t his cup of tea,” Sandy says. “Mike’s more of a professional type, you might say.”

Chris, though, always wanted to be part of the company. He joined the business full time 15 years ago, shortly after finishing college.

“I think of it almost as a member of the family,” he says of the company.

Hurst, left, and Southwood used a crane on the back of the company truck to unload a monument at Fairview Cemetery in Jasper on Nov. 20.

He puts in long hours, often working on nights and weekends. But the work is rarely dull.

One customer wanted his Social Security number engraved on his tombstone. Others have wanted a whiskey bottle or marijuana leaf etched next to their name.

“Some odd things,” Chris says with a chuckle.

But the most frustrating cases are when customers try to cram their entire life onto a tombstone.
“If you do that, then you have this stone that makes no sense,” says Susan, who has been with the company for 10 years.

Customers usually come to that realization once the lettering is sketched on an order form. The company doesn’t charge extra for a wordy epitaph, but those who do the engraving only have so much surface area to work with.

Oftentimes, customers “realize it’s not going to work,” Susan says, so they pare it down.

Jack and Sandy hope the company stays in the family a few more generations. Susan’s son, Nick, plans to work alongside his family once he graduates from the University of Southern Indiana, where he is studying business. If he had his druthers, he would drop out of school and start work now.

“I told him, ”˜Get your college education,’” Susan says.

Jack nodded in agreement.

“You can always fall back on that if something happens,” he says. “Hopefully, we’ll be here another 125 years, but you never know.”

Whenever an employee has a birthday, co-workers make and share a lunch together in celebration. Sandy Troth, second from right, cut the homemade strawberry cake while her daughter, Susan Teaford, scooped the ice cream Sept. 19 to celebrate the birthday of Don Werne of Dale, second from left. At left is Jack Troth.

The shop, built almost a century ago, is a monument to monuments.

A records vault on the building’s west end is filled with copies of transactions dating back more than a century. The contracts are in remarkable shape given their age.

Other parts of the building contain relics from a time gone by. In the back is a wire saw, once used to cut giant slabs of stone into smaller, more geometric contours.

Machinery near the loading area smoothed and polished the stones. The old contraptions still work but haven’t been used in years.

“Really, it’s a museum piece,” Jack says of the polishing machine.

In the 1960s, the family began phasing out the equipment in the back of the building. It was more cost effective to buy stones that were already cut and polished. Engraving, though, is still done in-house.

Most business owners would toss out the artifacts and use the space for something else. But nostalgia has a hold on Jack and Sandy.

Both are sentimentalists at heart. They would consider it sacrilege to get rid of the old equipment and contracts.

Every so often, someone will come in and ask about a monument from the 1940s or earlier.

“And you pull a contract out, and they say, ”˜Look, there’s grandma’s signature,’” Jack says.

After installing a monument at Fairview Cemetery in Jasper on Nov. 20, Jon Hurst of Dale scrubbed it clean. Hurst and co-worker Garrett Southwood of Newburgh installed five monuments that morning.

Over time, technology changes.

“But this technology,” he says, pointing to a paper contract, “if it doesn’t burn will be here for another hundred years. Stuff on that computer, what’s going to be around for another hundred years?”

Nothing, of course, lasts forever. But the words etched on a tombstone will outlive everyone at Schum Monuments and probably will outlive the business itself.

A tombstone shows that somebody lived, that somebody died and that somebody mattered. The people who work here understand this.

And that’s why, after all these years, Schum Monuments is still around.

“I feel incredibly blessed,” Sandy says as her eyes filled with tears. “And now I’ve got two kids working here and a grandson very interested in the business.

“I’m so blessed … so blessed.”

Contact Tony Raap at traap@dcherald.com.




More on DuboisCountyHerald.com

  • Miner & Mother

    Amanda Jones of Dubois has proven herself in two far different worlds — the profession of coal...
  • Game On

    At Game Knight in downtown Huntingburg, the games are involved and the sense of community is...
  • A Legacy On Target

    The crafting of guns is often passed from father to son. Ferdinand native Marvin Kemper quit his...
  • Images of 2014

    This week, The Herald’s photojournalists write about their favorite photographs of last year.
  • Christmas Comes To Life

    The live Nativity at St. Henry Catholic Church dates back to 1998. It’s a cherished tradition.
  • Nuts About Pecans

    Tom Schmitt learned about pecan farming from his father. It’s a tradition he appreciates and a...
  • Honorable Scout

    David Thyen is one of the more than 250 members of Holy Family Boy Scout Troop 185 to become an...
  • Grand Parents

    When their daughter and son-in-law were called to serve with the U.S. Air Force in Afghanistan,...